Michael Deutch has written this blog recently:
To prompt discussion about using MindManager on the Tablet PC. For some reason that neither Michael or I can work out my comments are not being published. I have tried from different PCs & browsers. So here is my positive and critical criticism of this mode:
Michael, thank you for referring to my efforts with the Tablet PC and MindManager above.
I have to admit to being someone who has used MindManager Ink mode a few times a week since 2005 when MindManager X5 Tablet became available. It has gone through 4 versions of HPs Tablet PCs currently a 2710p but the TC1100 was the best!
I use it in these three modes:
First: for personal brainstorming. Often standing up and away from the office desk.
Second: for personal note taking and often producing the minutes at meetings.
Third: for recording and publishing events on the web. Frequently I work with teams of people like Maurice mentioned and linked in your blog, to produce a comprehensive record of public and private events. These range from individual speakers, to management meetings, to two day annual conferences, to a rock festival. Using MindManager for three days in a field and in the dark later in the day must be one of the extreme uses.
Using MindManager ink mode is much less instrusive to the meeting than using a keyboard and a more fluid recording process.
MindManager ink mode is a core tool for ConferenceREACTION and the web export is used to produce all the web sites.
BUT MindManager ink mode has been frustrating me since 2005. Why?
1. The eraser on the end of my stylus does not work in MindManager. It does in all other applications.
2. The colour of the ink is not the colour of the converted text. It becomes the default colour.
3. The ink to text conversion was comparatively good on release in 2005. Better than XPs TabTIP but Vista overtook it and Windows 7 streaks away into the distance.
4. The conversion of ink to graphic images is poor. Primary concern is the conversion of sketches but it also applies when you want to put an Ink mind map in a document or on a web page. Borders appear around the ink and there is a granularity not present in the native MindManager map.
5. The clicking the ink colour tool does not return the stylus to ink mode from eraser mode but clicking the ink thickness tool does.
6. The lasso tool (ink dragging) is often sluggish taking several seconds to settle into the new position.
7. The high CPU usage of MindManager in general and the extreme CPU usage e.g. > 60% CPU time when the stylus is applied to the screen. Not good for someone who inking all day! This halves the battery life of Tablet PCs.
8. That there has been no significant development of ink mode since 2005!
9. I would like the mode to be associated with the map. That is when I change from a map I am editing in ink mode to a map that was previously being edited in mouse mode I want the the mode to change to mouse mode.
Despite all the above I will continue to use MindManager Ink mode because it does a brilliant job. You can just do it in pictures.
!
